Comparing Major Stone-Coated Steel Shingle Manufacturers: Which One is Best for Your Roof?
When it comes to durable, long-lasting roofing materials, stone-coated steel shingles are an excellent choice for homeowners looking for the aesthetics of traditional shingles, tiles, or shakes with the strength of metal roofing. These shingles offer superior weather resistance, fire resistance, and energy efficiency, making them a great investment for long-term home protection.
Several manufacturers dominate the stone-coated steel roofing market, each offering unique products with various benefits. In this blog, we’ll compare the top brands: DECRA, Tilcor, Boral (Westlake Royal Roofing), and Roser to help you determine which one is right for your home.
- DECRA: The Industry Pioneer
Pros:
✅ Industry leader with decades of experience
✅ Wide variety of styles and colors
✅ Highly durable with strong wind and impact resistance
✅ Best-in-class warranties
Cons:
❌ Premium pricing
❌ Some styles may have limited availability in certain regions
DECRA is one of the most well-known brands in the stone-coated steel roofing industry and is often considered the pioneer of this technology. The company offers a range of products, including DECRA Shingle XD, DECRA Shake, and DECRA Tile, giving homeowners several style options.
One of the biggest advantages of DECRA roofing is its exceptional durability—these shingles are Class 4 impact-resistant and can withstand winds up to 120 mph. Additionally, DECRA products come with a lifetime limited warranty, making them a strong long-term investment. However, their premium price point may be a downside for homeowners on a budget.
- Tilcor: High-Performance and Environmentally Friendly
Pros:
✅ Strong wind resistance (rated up to 160 mph)
✅ Energy-efficient and eco-friendly
✅ Advanced interlocking system for superior strength
✅ Made from high-quality New Zealand steel
Cons:
❌ Slightly fewer style options compared to competitors
❌ Availability can vary by region
Tilcor is a New Zealand-based manufacturer that has gained a strong reputation in North America for its high-performance roofing products. Their stone-coated steel shingles are known for their robust interlocking design, which enhances wind resistance and weatherproofing.
Tilcor’s roofing materials are crafted from New Zealand steel, one of the purest forms of steel available. This results in a lighter yet incredibly strong product. Their products, like the Tilcor CF Shingle and Tilcor CF Shake, feature a concealed fastening system for improved protection against leaks.
Tilcor shingles are also energy-efficient, with a focus on reducing heat absorption and lowering cooling costs. However, their fewer style options may be a drawback for homeowners looking for highly customized aesthetics.
- Boral (Westlake Royal Roofing): A Trusted Name in Roofing
Pros:
✅ Backed by a well-established roofing company
✅ Great variety of tile, shingle, and shake styles
✅ Class 4 impact-resistant and strong wind ratings
✅ Environmentally friendly materials
Cons:
❌ Warranty coverage can be complex
❌ Slightly heavier than some competitors
Boral (now Westlake Royal Roofing) is a major player in the roofing industry and offers high-quality stone-coated steel roofing systems. Their product lineup includes popular styles such as Pine-Crest Shake, Barrel-Vault Tile, and Pacific Tile.
Boral products are engineered for durability, with Class 4 impact resistance and wind resistance up to 120 mph. These shingles are also eco-friendly, made from recyclable materials, and contribute to energy efficiency with their high solar reflectivity.
One drawback of Boral’s roofing systems is their warranty structure, which can be a bit more complicated than competitors like DECRA. Additionally, some of their products are slightly heavier, which may require additional roof reinforcement.
- Roser: Affordable and Reliable
Pros:
✅ Competitive pricing compared to premium brands
✅ Strong impact and wind resistance
✅ High energy efficiency ratings
✅ Good range of styles and colors
Cons:
❌ Not as widely recognized in North America
❌ Warranty coverage may not be as extensive as DECRA
Roser is a South Korean-based company that has been gaining popularity in the U.S. for its affordable yet durable stone-coated steel roofing. Their product lineup includes Roser Cleo Tile, Roser Stonewood Shake, and Roser Piano Shingle, providing a good variety of styles.
One of the main advantages of Roser roofing is its affordability compared to other premium brands like DECRA and Boral. Despite the lower price, their products still feature Class 4 impact resistance and strong wind ratings.
However, since Roser is not as widely established in North America, finding a local installer or warranty support may be more difficult. Additionally, their warranties are generally solid but not as comprehensive as those offered by DECRA.
Which Stone-Coated Steel Roofing Brand is Right for You?
The best manufacturer for your home depends on your budget, climate, and style preferences:
- Best Overall Quality & Warranty: DECRA
- Best Wind & Weather Resistance: Tilcor
- Best for Style & Aesthetic Variety: Boral (Westlake Royal Roofing)
Best Budget-Friendly Option: Roser
